Cell Phones and Cheating

An interesting post was written on LeaderTalk the other day which really hit home with me. The post was titled: General thoughts on handheld technology and assessment (a boring title, but hopefully a good discussion) by Matt Hillmann.  Matt writes about the use of handheld devices in school and about the concept of cheating among students. I was interested in this because I had written a post on the topic of cell phones a few months ago, and just the other day I had a conversation with a colleague about cheating in school.

Here is my take on cell phones and cheating. If we stop giving one answer multiple choice or true/false tests, we can worry less about cheating. Such tests typically assume that the teacher imparts the content to the students all at the same time (e.g.lecture), the students then memorize the information and regurgitate it back to the teacher. If the teacher gives the same exact information to all of the students in the class, then there are no secrets. All of the students have equal access to that information, however, some kids can memorize better than others.  Does that mean they have learned the concepts better?

Instead of using a testing system that is older than John Dewey, teachers should require the students to use the information to solve authentic problems, or to explain or demonstrate their understanding in creative, unique, and different ways. In other words, allow the students to discuss and use the information to problem solve instead of memorize and then forget.

In your daily work, how often do you have to memorize information and repeat it back to your boss? Probably not too often.  Instead, we all use the resources available to us to do our jobs well.

Teachers should be encouraging students to work together and to use all available resources to find answers to challenging problems and questions. If that means a calculator, a computer, a cell phone phone call, or a text message, then that should be allowed. The information is out there – Kids need to learn how to access and use it to solve real, authentic problems, not to memorize and then forget.


2 thoughts on “Cell Phones and Cheating

  1. Seth,
    Wordpress has been good so far. At the district level, people are talking about the newest version of Sharepoint having blogging capabilities. I am not so sure about that, but I am seeing a demo of it this morning. If I don’t like it, I will create another WordPress blog to use for the parent community like I do with my The Principal’s Page blog (http://blog109.org/communities/mrsherman/default.aspx).

    The bigger issue for me, and one that I have been communicating with Alan November and Brian Mull about, is that when NL shuts down their blogging service, everything will be lost – disappear into the blogosphere. I have three years of posts and other stuff out there that I do not want to lose.

    I have hooked up Net56 engineers to work with the NL people to see it there is a way to save or archive all of our work – district wide- on the NL blogs.

    Are you going to hear Alan speak later this month? I was asked by the Midwest Principals’ Center to introduce him! I am looking forward to it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s